Saturday, October 1, 2016

"Empty Me" by Jeremy Camp: A metaphysical and theological nightmare marked with good intentions

Across Franciscan, Christian radio, and other places where contemporary music is sung or played, the song "Empty Me," introduced by Jeremy Camp, has become a staple. As we sung it today on campus, I found myself unable to sing the lyrics. While the song was written with good intentions, we as christians can learn from the days of the Christological councils that defining our terms and basing our teachings on sound philosophy is essential. Otherwise, you can easily end up with something like arianism, nestorianism.... or "Empty Me." Let me explain why.

The song starts with "Holy fire, burn away my desire for anything that is not you and is of me." There are a number of underlying errors in that line alone. First of all, a holy fire in order to burn something has to imply that that something exists. But everything that exists is good. Evil is the LACKING of a good, and a void cannot be burned. One may counter argue that my desire itself can be burned away, but is a desire that is disordered inherently BAD? I say no, a desire for something not of God is good insofar as it is a desire for a perceived good. What is bad is not the desire but the faulty attribution of "good" to something that is either disordered (having a lacking of a good) or out of place (good but not good for this situation.) Furthermore, to say "is of me" as a distinguishment from "of You" is also inaccurate. A more accurate wording would be "anything that is not of you and just/only of me" but even then it would still not give clarity to the truth that all desires that are not of God are wrong not on account of being of me but on account of being disordered. The notion that I am bad, which underlies this verse, is the classic notion that grace cannot cleanse me but merely is a cover-up, like snow covers a dung heap.

The song continues with "I want more of you and less of me." This continues the aforementioned implication that I am bad, I am the dung heap rather than a human made in God's image. A better rendition would be "I want more of You, that's best for me." For who is God but the Way, the Truth, and the Life. (Jn 14:6) Basically, there is no gap between true human fulfillment and more of God for the glory of God is man fully alive. In essence, having more of God means more of the true me. He cannot increase if I decrease; if He increases, I by default increase as Him in me increases me. So I would say that I would want more of Him, and in wanting and receiving more of Him I end up with more of the true me. The lyrics as they are again have implicit in them the error that I am bad, worthless, not made in His image.

The song uses as a refrain, "empty me, fill me with you." If what is sinful, distorted, or imperfect in me is not a positive existence of evil but an absence of good, I merely need to be filled. And maybe healed first.

So I will write the words I would sing.

Holy fire, purify
my desire for anything
when it's not of you, and bad for me
I want more of You, that's best for me.

Heal me, heal me, fill me, won't You fill me, with You, with You!

No comments:

Post a Comment