A
recent article published by a student in the Odyssey has discussed
twenty aspects of life at Franciscan. This article has elicited a
number of responses by students, who, having read the article, have
weighed in on the pros and cons of our beloved Franciscan University.
I am here to weigh in constructively, in order to work towards a
synthesis. But first, I must make a disclaimer.
While the
majority of students chose to attend Franciscan as a free-will
decision or at least a free-will decision in response to a fair
situation, there are some who have come because they want to be
anywhere but here but their parents forced them to come. If you are
reading this, and that is your situation, I am not writing to you.
You are understandably frustrated with what should be a good thing
but has become to you the manifestation of a superior's will upon you
and rightfully feels like a restriction. However, the vast majority
of you have come freely. Many chose this school from a number of
valid options or sought it out directly. Some chose it as most
advantageous on account of the commuter grant or on account of the
parents' desire to fund the education on condition you come here.
This situation I argue as a free will choice because, your parents
worked for that money and it is theirs, so they have the right to say
where it is being spent. But you also have a free will, and have no
obligation to go to this school or school at all, or you would
instead be in the first category, those forced to
attend.
Furthermore, I am not making any
implications as to the situation of the original writer. All that I
will say about her is the facts; that she wrote the article in the
Odyssey and that we are to take her words at face value, or ask her
what she meant by them so as to understand what she is trying to say.
Likewise, take my words at face value, or ask me what it is that I am
trying to say. All I request is politeness. I will engage in respectful dialogue. Personal attacks, vehement debates,
chastisement, and similar, in this situation where I am open to
friendly dialogue, are not consistent with the lifestyle we seek to
lead.
With this being said, I will weigh in on the points.
1:
"It's crazy expensive:"
Franciscan, compared to
other private schools, is not expensive. On account of many private
schools costing equal or greater, I would say it is in the standard
cost for education. Room and board is relatively less expensive as
well. For example, in 2013, Southern Connecticut State University was
charging approximately 125% of what Franciscan was charging for a
dorm room and a full mealplan. And that is a state school.
At
Franciscan, you are paying for an education as well as a Catholic
atmosphere. I think that if that is what you desire, then you are
getting a good deal. If you are here because of the grant or parental
money allocation, you are still getting a good deal. If they want to
pay $120k for you to go here, it's their money and their decision. So
bottom line, it is college itself, not this specific college, that is
pricey. Thus, the issue is with the education system itself and not
Franciscan University.
2: "There's an obscene amount of
rules, and half of them seem completely unnecessary."
There
are a lot of rules, but rules are at the service of the common good.
Every rule has a reason or purpose; most rules are in place on
account of past behavior that was contrary to the common good and
needed to be regulated.
I am not going to get up here and say
that we should like the rules, nor get up here and say that we should
worship the rules, nor get up and say that we should agree with the
rules. All I am saying is that we should accept them.
The
only example the article gives is the prohibition of using tape on
the walls. Tape leaves a residue of glue on the walls, especially if
there for a while. Especially duct tape, sometimes clear tape, even
masking tape if long enough. Tape also can be difficult to remove,
creating a problem for the maintenance staff. They have to invest
more hours scraping the glue and repainting the rooms more often,
increasing costs in labor and materials. More work = more expenses =
higher tuition. It may be a drop in the bucket, but it adds up. So in
essence, the rule may seem a little tacky (pun intended) but the rule
is there to protect the common good.
Rules can do the
following: They can directly encourage what is better for the student
or deter what is detrimental. For example, no late night noise so we
can sleep, no illegal drug usage. No excessive drinking. Rules can
honor what is the county, state, and national rule. For example, no
underage drinking. If you are 20 and drink a beer, is it necessarily
going to harm you? Anyone who has been to Austria can validly say no.
But as a Catholic, what can harm you is the act of violating a rule
by a valid authority. I might not like the fact that I cannot have a
beer with some of my friends but I have to respect and obey the rule.
And understand that the reason we even have such a rule (21 to drink
contrasted with 16 in Austria, etc.,) is because historically, we as
Americans have shown we are not trustworthy with that resource. So in
this example, the proper response is to change the culture through
heightened awareness on how to properly use alcohol. Rules can also
be indirectly in your best interest. For example, you want (or most
students want) a good education in a Catholic atmosphere. But in
order to keep enrollment full, parents need to have confidence their
children are in a good environment. Overprotective parents will be
turned off by, for example, certain types of PDA or a laxity in hall
rules regarding visitation. If they stop sending their children here
and the school loses its reputation as a reliable Catholic school,
then enrollment will drop and that will adversely affect the student
body. The administration is well aware of the many rising Catholic
schools across the nation that, like Franciscan, adhere to the
Church's teachings like we do. Or in business terms, increased
competition. So while the rule may rightfully seem excessive, we
accept it because it seeks to serve the common good.
Should we
just accept the rules blindly? Rather; we should dialogue about them
politely with the people of influence, especially if they sanction
devices which solicit feedback such as surveys, opportunities for
feedback, or engage in discussion to ascertain which ways they may
consider tweaking the rule to appeal to the students' interest
without eroding the common good. Remember, the rules that we accept
are not perfect, and the authorities are human. We therefore, should
work towards a better system in a constructive and respectful
way.
3: "In many ways, you are treated like a
child."
Are we evidencing that we are acting like adults,
or do we still need an exterior force to coerce us to do what we are
supposed to ordinarily do? For example, room checks. While one might
argue that we should be able to keep our rooms clean because we are
adults, I have had roommates who do not respect the shared space and
are not on top of their dishes, clutter, etc., and thus impede the usability of the shared space. For this reason, we need room checks.
We need them not as much to tell us what to do but more to motivate
us to do what we as adults already know that we should be doing. The
room check, quiet hours, and similar rules are there to ensure a
shared lifestyle that is harmonious to the needs of the community and
to reduce behavior that impedes it e.g. late night noise, messy
rooms, etc.
4: "The academics are intensive and
rigorous"
Absolutely. Proclaim this from the rooftop, but
embrace it. Just as pain in the gym translates to muscular strength,
so too academic pain translates to better learning.
5:
"There isn't a decent night life."
A decent night
life is not a requirement for a college, and perhaps the lack of one
reflects that it is not a big deal for many of the students and
locals. Or they do things differently in this area. Otherwise, you
think that someone would have tried to open businesses that provided
a nightlife, no? I would have to do research as to whether it just
hasn't been done or whether it has not been profitable before I
challenge you to be that entrepreneur.
Furthermore, what is
nightlife and how essential is it in actuality? An argument can be
made for the need to break from campus and work, and I will grant to
that. An argument can be made that productive students need breaks to
be productive and I will grant that too. But these are general
arguments as opposed to arguments that specifically demand an
off-campus nightlife. The original statement that "there isn't a
decent night life" asserts that there is an unfilled need for a
night life, and begs the question which I will ask: from a catholic
perspective, what constitutes a decent night life?
6: "Walking
off campus leads nowhere except to your potential murder."
At
face value, the author is saying that you need a car if you are to go
anywhere off campus, due to the dangers in the city. However, a
serious concern demands a seious response, and the university has
hired a full time employee to oversee works of mercy that are done in
cooperation with the church, the city, and other non-profit
organizations in and around Steubenville. Every year, 15+ students
spend their spring break doing mission work at the sites throughout
the city, and another group of 10-20 students stay a week after
school and do the same. Furthermore, 20-30 students oversee different
works of mercy in the Steubenville area that hundreds of students
participate in weekly. Furthermore, as students in Steubenville, we
have the opportunity to be a witness to Christ in our daily
interactions. So while this is a valid concern, let's do something
about it.
7: "Like any other college, how much money they
can get out of you is a priority."
I would like concrete
evidence to support this claim. Is there something wrong with the
university being an operating business model that has ways of income
to offset its expenditures and have the potency to earn a profit it
can then reinvest in making the university better? On the one hand,
we complain that it is expensive, then we complain when things aren't
the best because of cost factors. We will revisit this in depth as we
continue, but for now, let me defer to our friends the Rolling
Stones, who remind us that we can't always get what we want.
8:
"The weather is more bipolar..."
Absolutely. I will
grant you this one. The cold and unpredictable aspect of the weather
is definitely something that "comes with the package."
9:
"People can be disgustingly judgmental."
At the end
of the day, we are human and we struggle with this. To be honest,
people at Franciscan are the least judgemental of those who I have
encountered. I say this not as a typical Frannie but as someone who
is a twofold anomaly; first as an older student and second that I
grow my hair out. If anyone should be judged it would be me.
Nonetheless, we are Catholic, and we need to love people where they
are at and reach out to them as Christ would. For that reason, when I
see people with long hair, tattoos, who wear black or leather etc, I
engage them in dialogue. Everyone has a story and our goal is to
encounter them in the point they are at. Many times, they are the
most authentic people you will meet. So while we are called to work
on this, to just say that we are judgemental and walk away lacks
anything constructive.
10: "Half the dorms don't have
AC."
I am going to bring our Rolling Stones friends back
in here. On the one hand, we complain about the cost of tuition, on
the other hand we complain that we don't have AC. On account that we
only really need AC in August and September, and a few days in May, I
have been just fine with a fan and lightweight clothing. There are no
rules against shorts and tank tops outside of the classroom and
chapel, both of which are air conditioned. While more AC is being
added as renovations continue, maybe the school should charge more
for the AC rooms and less for the non AC rooms. I know, not having AC
can be a bit uncomfortable but be thankful we have fans, modern
medicine, and internet....oh wait. What's this?
11: "The
campus wifi sucks. Everywhere."
Well, we DO have
internet. Is it always reliable? No. It went out the other day, and I
was not happy with that, but at least OIT had it up within an hour.
Yes, we have had more than our fair share of outages, but that comes
with the terretory. If we had better internet, we would have to pay
more. Plus, what we have now is way better than the internet we had
ten to fifteen years ago. Our generation gets enough criticism as it
is, we don't want to validate it by complaining about the internet
all the time. Is resnet great? No, it has its outages and glitches.
Am I happy when it goes out? No. But rather than complain, let's be
more constructive with time management. There are offline things one
can do during that time; maybe get dinner, go to chapel, do homework,
etc. I understand that in this age, we are used to doing what we want
when we want to but in past ages, we had to do things based on
opportunity. I couldn't do stuff online the other day so I did my
assigned homework for my theology class that I was planning on doing
later that day. But let's be honest, not everyone has the Rolling
Stones on their playlists offline, and internet is needed to get on
youtube and play 'You can't always get what you want.'
12:
"It's located in steubenville OH"
I already
addressed this in #6.
13: "A third of the professors
think they're some sort of god."
Ah, yes the legendary
senior thesis I mean syllabus. One of my dreams is to be a professor.
When I make it, I will be clear with my expectations, expect respect
and class attendance, and demand commitment from my students. But in
a world where students and professors have equal human dignity as
persons, the best way to demand respect is through the act of
respecting the people one desires respect from. Doing so will earn
one credibility with those under him, and that opens them to be
receptive to the message the professor seeks to impart. Am I
defending the 12 page syllabus on classroom rules? Let's just say that
maybe more constructive dialogue may lead to a greater awareness of
what is helpful and what hinders students respecting and learning
from professors in pedagogical methods in the classroom. But let us
cut our professors a little slack, and network with students so we
can have a better idea of what professors we want to take. That is
the most effective way to alter professor behavior. Professors pay
attention to what makes students pick one over another, and most
professors are at least open to improvement.
14: "Austria
is like (pleasure island)."
A: How it makes or breaks
relationships: So it tests them early on, tests them with fire. If
they are meant to be, they will endure. But let's get some
constructive brainstorming to assemble a resource that helps students
going to Austria understand how this semester will affect and impact
their relationship, so that they can be prepared and know how to
respond.
B: The drinking problem varies from semester to
semester. In my semester, there were not that many incidents. But we
are adults and we are to make responsible decisions. If we cannot
control our drinking, we have nobody but ourselves to blame for a
lack of discretion and self-discipline that indicates a missed
opportunity to grow in virtue and hold ourselves and each other
accountable. And I say this as one of you. I would look at alcohol
content in everything, know how much was in me, be attuned to how I
was responding to the alcohol, drink at a steady but slower pace so
to be in tune with my response before too much was in my system, stay
hydrated, and go on alcohol fasts for a day or a few days about once
a month to make sure I wasn't dependent on it. Do I expect you to be
at this level? No, but I do expect you to strive for it.
C: I
did not have much of a problem with the internet... because I was
almost never on it. Now, don't get me wrong, the internet is an
awesome resource and I spend a lot of time on it interacting over
social media, researching, and playing video games. But Austria was
my once in a lifetime opportunity to study and travel in foreign
countries with my friends. The classes were top quality and the
majority of my work I did offline. I copy-pasted/screenshot what I
needed or used the unlimited print budget I had there for stuff
online I needed later. It taught me to plan and prepare. As I could
network and play games when I returned to America, I threw myself
fully into the experience, and had the best semester of my life. I
was fine with half hour of internet a day to stay in contact and do
work, I seldom needed more time than that. Now, it is not for
everyone, but for me it exceeded the expectations and advertisements.
Maybe I was better suited for it as I had lived on my own before and
was used to being away from home. I was only homesick on one day...
it was after I returned to America that I had a rough time. But
again, always look into what is being advertized, see if it is right
for you, and ask the questions and decide if it is right for
you.
15: "Households are far too idolized."
"The
peer-pressure to join a household is almost as bad as the
peer-pressure for girls to get their MRS degree."
That is
the argument, at face value. So let me address that.
The peer
pressure to join household is like when your friends see a great
movie and tell you that you have to see it. It is like when your
friends go to a great place and tell you you have to go. It is like
when your friends have a great meal and tell you you have to try it
too. Most likely, they have had an awesome experience in household
and want you to have an awesome experience.
Household is not
for everyone. Understand that those in household chose it because
they wanted household life and the specific experience of the
household they chose. What is working for them is not guaranteed to
work for you. Check out a number of households, and you will have a
good idea of whether you fit in with one or decide that household
life just isn't your thing. What is important is that you get
involved in something. Household is great, but it isn't the only
option. On the one hand, I am glad that they are not mandatory. On
the other hand, I think that they are great and those who dismiss
household life make the same error as those who carry on like it's
the way to go for everyone; the error is this: to forget that what is
good (the best thing) for one person is not necessarily good (the
best thing) for everyone. So let households be households, and be
ready to explain respectfully why they just aren't your thing. If
anything, it is an opportunity for discussion with household members
why household wasn't your thing, which can be an opportunity to grow
in mutual understanding.
As for the Mrs. Degree, what
pressure? I have been here seven semesters and a member of the
minority sex and I have been on 0 dates with students. Maybe my age
is a reason for friend-zoning, but if Mary and Joseph were the ages
they were, and this school looks to them as models to emulate, I rest
my case that this pressure doesn't exist on a universal level on this
campus.
16: "Laundry is expensive."
It costs
to provide and maintain the machines and to use the water for
laundry, plus the company needs to turn a profit. So I agree that it
is expensive but that's one of the necessary evils of this life for
the reasons I gave, so I might as well accept that that is what it is
and deal with it.
17: "The water is toxic."
There
are filters in the fieldhouse and now in the St. Joseph's center.
Maybe we can petition one in each dorm; this would be a constructive
response. We can also buy filtration devices to use. Trust me, there
are municipalities that have worse water than Steubenville and I come
from one.
18: "Your alcohol is limited and your cuddling
micromanaged"
Alcohol is limited because of liability
issues. It is less about telling us what to do and more about making
it hard to commit obscene violations. The limit is more to prevent
excessive binge drinking and to limit the amount of alcohol at
parties to a manageable amount. Remember, it has less to do with
whether Franciscan trusts you to be responsible and more to do with
the precedent set on American campuses. These rules are in place in
order to preserve the school's identity and ability to live up to the
expectations parents place upon it. Therefore, the limitation of
alcohol should be regarded not as much as a restriction but as
something we accept on account of the greater good. At least we are
able to drink on this campus. There are some schools that prohibit it
altogether.
Perhaps cuddling is micromanaged, but perhaps we
should embrace (no pun intended) this rule as an opportunity for us
to practice restraint and patience. Not everyone is at that point
where they can stay pure in the face of temptation. It is in the
school's best interest to uphold standards which are designed to
allow romance to develop yet allow it to do so in a way less likely
to lead to sin. Sometimes it can feel like micromanagement but it is
for the common good as this is a place where we are growing in virtue
and there are a lot of things that we can do in a relationship to
express our love for each other. I know several friends in
relationships who have never complained about the rules. Remember,
there is always a bit of trade-off in everything, and we can't always
get everything we want. Life is about weighing options and picking
that which is most of an advantage or opportunity rather than the
perfect option because the latter seldom exists. The school is open
to discussion in this regard. After a number of survey feedbacks,
they added Saturday open hours for students. So there is always the
opportunity for constructive dialogue.
19: "The cafeteria
has rules that are just plain stupid."
Ad hominem aside,
they are adding guest swipes; I believe three per semester but this
is a topic under discussion. Points can be used to swipe in guests.
As for swiping multiple times, students buy say a 19 meal per week
plan but don't usually use all 19 meals. Multiple swipes would
improve efficiency and meal allocation. But it would also ramp up
costs. The trade-off is that meal plan prices will likely rise as a
result.
In my four years here, I have seen an improvement in
food quality and an increase in late night from two days a week to
almost every day. The cafeteria is open to constructive feedback and
suggestions so there is plenty of opportunity for constructive
feedback.
20: "The bookstore is a ripoff"
I
will defer to the big poster of the dollar bill above the textbook
window in the bookstore and explain where the money goes. Then you
can give 9% of the blame to this aspect of the business, 4% to that
aspect etc.
What I do is look for opportunities. I buy books
from other students, sell books I no longer need, use library books
in some cases (e.g., for a book report or similar one-off read/uses
rather than an all-semester usage) and use the internet for vatican
documents and books in the public domain. So there are ways to reduce
the costs.
So in conclusion, yes there are things that can be
better. But let's look at the good things we have going at this
school and seek to get involved and take constructive action rather
than complain about how things can be better. Together, we can make a
difference.
The inspirations, thoughts, and realizations of a man who seeks to inspire many to work together to make the world a better place.
Friday, January 27, 2017
Thursday, January 12, 2017
To the critiques of Pope Francis: The logic applies on both sides of the field.
A recent facebook post was made by a friend to the tune of that he had never had to question the Holy Father until Pope Francis came along. While the post itself was innocent and without the intentions that this blog post will decry, the responses were mostly a group effort to question and to even dismiss the Holy Father. Why do these "Catholics" have a problem with the Holy Father? Because he is not catholic enough for them. The basis and foundation for their sentiments is the desire to return to or uphold authentic Catholicism.
But for this reason, they are NOT helping but only further eroding authentic Catholicism.
If one has as one's basis the desire for authentic solid and true Catholicism, it follows that that person in all his actions will promote and uphold authentic Catholicism. But it is not authentic Catholicism to sow seeds of dissent among the faithful about their own leader. It is a basic "ends justify the means" mentality here. If the ends are to restore the Church to authenticity, it is OK to undercut the Pope, question the Pope, openly dissent with the Pope, cultivate public distrust and dissent among the faithful about the Pope? I say no. In the name of the Church they are weakening and eroding the Church.
I must say this right now: If you want to see the restoration of authentic Catholicism, and the Pope is focusing on the environment, making ambiguous or misunderstood statements, and is perceived by you and your peers as a modernist, here is a list of the following things that you must do, and the things that you must not do, if I am going to see you as sincere in your quest for the restoration of authentic Catholicism and not a hypocrite or a self-righteous modern-day pharisee.
Do these things:
1: Write facebook posts, blog posts, scholarly works, books, videos, and other media directly addressing the dogma or doctrine that the Pope has made the statement on. Do not mention the Pope. Simply mention the teaching itself, show what the Church says on it, bring up the opposing views (including the one that you feel the Pope is promoting, without mentioning the Pope) and then answer these opposing views using the Church teachings. If you mention the Pope or quote his words, do so in a way that clarifies and explains how his words are in conformance with Church teaching rather than bash him or his words. (See #5).
2: Refrain from talking about the Pope at all. In some cases you can say "pray for the Pope." For you say that the Pope should be able to realize that his comments on planes are causing dissension in some listeners and amend his modus operandi. Yet your comments on social media are not any different. You should also be able to realize the dissension that is ensuing in some listeners and amend your modus operandi. Otherwise, you are not practicing what you preach and I cannot see that as anything other than hypocrisy.
3: Pray for the Pope daily.
4: Avoid reading about the Pope's messages or critiques on the Pope if they get you going and lead you away from these goals.
5: Seek to see the Pope as our leader and clarify rather than criticize what he says (see #1). Use this critical axiom: A: The pope as pope intends to be faithful to the Church. B: The pope said (quote). C: Therefore, if the pope is A, then B must mean C (an explanation of what the Church teaches.)
Don't do these:
1: Openly criticise the Pope, openly question rather than explain, openly cultivate doubt and dissent. Always seek to explain rather than question or diss.
2: Avoid doing everything I said not to do in the above section.
If your goal is to restore authentic Catholicism, and for the sake of it you go and cultivate dissent, doubt, and disobedience, I cannot see you as anything better than a hypocrite. No criticism of religious leaders is ever justified because there always is the better alternative of explanation of the doctrine and clarification of the teaching. Therefore, to those who criticise the Pope... I will address you in Christian charity. Look at how your readers are responding, zone in on what is making them respond negatively, and amend your style to move them from criticising the Pope to where they instead seek to explain the truth that we (using the above axiom) assume the Pope is trying to teach.
But for this reason, they are NOT helping but only further eroding authentic Catholicism.
If one has as one's basis the desire for authentic solid and true Catholicism, it follows that that person in all his actions will promote and uphold authentic Catholicism. But it is not authentic Catholicism to sow seeds of dissent among the faithful about their own leader. It is a basic "ends justify the means" mentality here. If the ends are to restore the Church to authenticity, it is OK to undercut the Pope, question the Pope, openly dissent with the Pope, cultivate public distrust and dissent among the faithful about the Pope? I say no. In the name of the Church they are weakening and eroding the Church.
I must say this right now: If you want to see the restoration of authentic Catholicism, and the Pope is focusing on the environment, making ambiguous or misunderstood statements, and is perceived by you and your peers as a modernist, here is a list of the following things that you must do, and the things that you must not do, if I am going to see you as sincere in your quest for the restoration of authentic Catholicism and not a hypocrite or a self-righteous modern-day pharisee.
Do these things:
1: Write facebook posts, blog posts, scholarly works, books, videos, and other media directly addressing the dogma or doctrine that the Pope has made the statement on. Do not mention the Pope. Simply mention the teaching itself, show what the Church says on it, bring up the opposing views (including the one that you feel the Pope is promoting, without mentioning the Pope) and then answer these opposing views using the Church teachings. If you mention the Pope or quote his words, do so in a way that clarifies and explains how his words are in conformance with Church teaching rather than bash him or his words. (See #5).
2: Refrain from talking about the Pope at all. In some cases you can say "pray for the Pope." For you say that the Pope should be able to realize that his comments on planes are causing dissension in some listeners and amend his modus operandi. Yet your comments on social media are not any different. You should also be able to realize the dissension that is ensuing in some listeners and amend your modus operandi. Otherwise, you are not practicing what you preach and I cannot see that as anything other than hypocrisy.
3: Pray for the Pope daily.
4: Avoid reading about the Pope's messages or critiques on the Pope if they get you going and lead you away from these goals.
5: Seek to see the Pope as our leader and clarify rather than criticize what he says (see #1). Use this critical axiom: A: The pope as pope intends to be faithful to the Church. B: The pope said (quote). C: Therefore, if the pope is A, then B must mean C (an explanation of what the Church teaches.)
Don't do these:
1: Openly criticise the Pope, openly question rather than explain, openly cultivate doubt and dissent. Always seek to explain rather than question or diss.
2: Avoid doing everything I said not to do in the above section.
If your goal is to restore authentic Catholicism, and for the sake of it you go and cultivate dissent, doubt, and disobedience, I cannot see you as anything better than a hypocrite. No criticism of religious leaders is ever justified because there always is the better alternative of explanation of the doctrine and clarification of the teaching. Therefore, to those who criticise the Pope... I will address you in Christian charity. Look at how your readers are responding, zone in on what is making them respond negatively, and amend your style to move them from criticising the Pope to where they instead seek to explain the truth that we (using the above axiom) assume the Pope is trying to teach.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)