Thursday, January 12, 2017

To the critiques of Pope Francis: The logic applies on both sides of the field.

A recent facebook post was made by a friend to the tune of that he had never had to question the Holy Father until Pope Francis came along. While the post itself was innocent and without the intentions that this blog post will decry, the responses were mostly a group effort to question and to even dismiss the Holy Father. Why do these "Catholics" have a problem with the Holy Father? Because he is not catholic enough for them. The basis and foundation for their sentiments is the desire to return to or uphold authentic Catholicism.

But for this reason, they are NOT helping but only further eroding authentic Catholicism.

If one has as one's basis the desire for authentic solid and true Catholicism, it follows that that person in all his actions will promote and uphold authentic Catholicism. But it is not authentic Catholicism to sow seeds of dissent among the faithful about their own leader. It is a basic "ends justify the means" mentality here. If the ends are to restore the Church to authenticity, it is OK to undercut the Pope, question the Pope, openly dissent with the Pope, cultivate public distrust and dissent among the faithful about the Pope? I say no. In the name of the Church they are weakening and eroding the Church.

I must say this right now: If you want to see the restoration of authentic Catholicism, and the Pope is focusing on the environment, making ambiguous or misunderstood statements, and is perceived by you and your peers as a modernist, here is a list of the following things that you must do, and the things that you must not do, if I am going to see you as sincere in your quest for the restoration of authentic Catholicism and not a hypocrite or a self-righteous modern-day pharisee.

Do these things:

1: Write facebook posts, blog posts, scholarly works, books, videos, and other media directly addressing the dogma or doctrine that the Pope has made the statement on. Do not mention the Pope. Simply mention the teaching itself, show what the Church says on it, bring up the opposing views (including the one that you feel the Pope is promoting, without mentioning the Pope) and then answer these opposing views using the Church teachings. If you mention the Pope or quote his words, do so in a way that clarifies and explains how his words are in conformance with Church teaching rather than bash him or his words. (See #5).

2: Refrain from talking about the Pope at all. In some cases you can say "pray for the Pope." For you say that the Pope should be able to realize that his comments on planes are causing dissension in some listeners and amend his modus operandi. Yet your comments on social media are not any different. You should also be able to realize the dissension that is ensuing in some listeners and amend your modus operandi. Otherwise, you are not practicing what you preach and I cannot see that as anything other than hypocrisy.

3: Pray for the Pope daily.

4: Avoid reading about the Pope's messages or critiques on the Pope if they get you going and lead you away from these goals.

5: Seek to see the Pope as our leader and clarify rather than criticize what he says (see #1). Use this critical axiom: A: The pope as pope intends to be faithful to the Church. B: The pope said (quote). C: Therefore, if the pope is A, then B must mean C (an explanation of what the Church teaches.)

Don't do these:

1: Openly criticise the Pope, openly question rather than explain, openly cultivate doubt and dissent. Always seek to explain rather than question or diss.

2: Avoid doing everything I said not to do in the above section.

If your goal is to restore authentic Catholicism, and for the sake of it you go and cultivate dissent, doubt, and disobedience, I cannot see you as anything better than a hypocrite. No criticism of religious leaders is ever justified because there always is the better alternative of explanation of the doctrine and clarification of the teaching. Therefore, to those who criticise the Pope... I will address you in Christian charity. Look at how your readers are responding, zone in on what is making them respond negatively, and amend your style to move them from criticising the Pope to where they instead seek to explain the truth that we (using the above axiom) assume the Pope is trying to teach.

No comments:

Post a Comment